Controversial Condominium Project Faces Multiple Obstacles in North Deering

Mar 10, 2025 at 8:00 AM

A proposed condominium development in North Deering is encountering significant opposition from various quarters, including local residents, environmental groups, and city officials. The project, spearheaded by GenX Capital Partners, aims to construct 54 units near the Presumpscot River Preserve. However, concerns about environmental impact, financial credibility, and outstanding debts have cast a shadow over its approval prospects. Additionally, the developer faces legal challenges due to unpaid fines for unauthorized tree removal, further complicating the situation.

Financial and Legal Challenges Plague Developer

The development company behind the Hope Avenue project is grappling with financial and legal hurdles that could delay or even derail the proposal. These issues include an unpaid fine related to previous violations and questions about the developer's ability to complete the project. The planning board may postpone approval until these matters are resolved.

GenX Capital Partners, led by Mark McClure, has accumulated substantial debts, including back taxes on the Hope Avenue property and liens on another luxury condominium community. McClure admitted to violating city regulations by removing trees without a permit and was ordered to pay $11,600. However, he has yet to make any payments, leading to a contempt order from the city. The unresolved debt issue is likely to influence the planning board's decision on the project's approval. Moreover, the company's history of financial mismanagement and poor construction practices at other sites raises doubts about its capability to deliver on this ambitious plan.

Environmental Concerns and Conservation Efforts

The proposed development near the Presumpscot River Preserve has sparked environmental concerns, particularly regarding the risk of landslides and habitat disruption. Neighbors and conservationists argue that the project could jeopardize the natural beauty and ecological integrity of the area. The city's land bank commission has expressed interest in acquiring the property for conservation purposes but faces obstacles due to the high asking price.

The soil study of the site reveals poorly drained soils derived from the Presumpscot Formation, a layer of soft clay that increases the likelihood of landslides. Irwin Novak, a geologist consulted by the Friends of the Presumpscot River, emphasized the heightened risk associated with heavy machinery and construction activities. He noted that the application does not adequately address these concerns. Meanwhile, the Portland Land Bank Commission remains interested in purchasing the land but finds the developer's offer of $2.75 million excessive. The commission is taking a cautious approach, awaiting further developments while advocating for careful consideration of the environmental impact. Residents like Jessie Pinchoff, who value the preserve's natural beauty, are urging the city to prioritize environmental protection over rapid development.